Why You Should Never Let an Employee Handle Both Sales and Stock (And How to Enforce Segregation of Duties with Login Permissions)

c
ceofounder
2 min read 179 views
Why You Should Never Let an Employee Handle Both Sales and Stock (And How to Enforce Segregation of Duties with Login Permissions)
Internal Controls

The One-Person Temptation

Your shop assistant, Mary, is fantastic. She handles customers, processes sales on the M-Pesa Till, and also receives deliveries and updates the stock book. She is a one-person dynamo. But this concentration of duties is the single biggest internal control weakness in a Kenyan SME.

It is not that Mary is dishonest. It is that the system makes it too easy for dishonesty to occur. Internal fraud thrives where one person controls both the recording of sales and the recording of stock.

The Temptation

One Person, All Access

  • Processes sales and handles cash
  • Updates stock levels manually
  • Can hide discrepancies
  • No independent oversight
  • High risk of undetected theft
The Control

Segregation of Duties

  • Sales clerk records orders
  • Stock controller receives goods
  • Manager approves adjustments
  • Dashboard flags exceptions
  • Honest staff protected

Why one person should not do both

If Mary can process a sale and update the stock, three specific risks emerge:

Risk 1

The Unrecorded Sale

She can sell an item, pocket the cash, and not record the sale. The stock count will be wrong, but because she controls that too, she can simply adjust the stock to cover the missing item.

Risk 2

The Short Delivery

She can receive a supplier delivery, record fewer items than actually arrived, and take the extra stock home. Without a second pair of eyes, the discrepancy is invisible.

Risk 3

The Fake Discount

She can issue unauthorised "discounts" to friends, undercharge for items, and cover the discrepancy with a stock adjustment, blaming it on shrinkage.

How to enforce SoD with login permissions

A Business Management Dashboard enforces Segregation of Duties (SoD) through role-based login permissions. Here is how the three roles should look.

👤

Role 1: Sales Clerk

  • Process sales (record an order, receive M-Pesa or cash)
  • Print receipts
  • Cannot: Adjust stock levels
  • Cannot: Void transactions (or limited voids with manager approval)
  • Cannot: Access supplier records
📦

Role 2: Stock Controller

  • Receive supplier deliveries and update stock levels
  • Perform stock takes and adjust inventory (with manager approval for large adjustments)
  • Cannot: Process sales
  • Cannot: Access the till
  • Cannot: Issue refunds
👑

Role 3: Manager / Owner

  • Full visibility of all transactions and stock movements
  • Approval of voids, large discounts, and significant stock adjustments
  • Access to Segregation of Duties reports

The small team exception

If you only have two employees, strict SoD is difficult. In that case, the dashboard provides the oversight layer.

The Oversight Layer

The SoD Exception Report

🚩
Daily Flagged Transaction Sales Clerk also adjusted stock

Any transaction where the same person handled both sale and stock is flagged in a daily "SoD Exception Report." The owner reviews these flagged transactions every evening.

The knowledge that the owner is reviewing exceptions acts as a powerful deterrent. It does not accuse the employee, but it removes the opportunity for silent theft.

The short version

Segregation of duties is not about mistrust. It is about building a system that protects honest employees from temptation and protects your business from loss.

Use role-based permissions to separate the recording of sales from the recording of stock.

Ready to secure your operations?

Stonehenge Digital builds business management systems with role-based access control, SoD exception reports, and transaction approval workflows, designed to protect your business and empower your team.

Set Up Role-Based Permissions →
Share Written by ceofounder

Interested in Business Management System?

Let's build this for your business

Replace spreadsheets, paper records, and WhatsApp chaos with a custom system built for exactly how your business works.

Leave a Comment

Share Your Thoughts